Discretionary Portfolio Service


Market Commentary 1st October 2011 - 31th December 2011


Taken in isolation, the final quarter of 2011 would ordinarily be considered one in which markets have delivered strong returns for investors. Most global equity markets have seen positive returns with the developed markets of the UK and US among the strongest. However, this has to be considered in the context of the previous quarter which saw double digit losses in those same markets which have not yet been recovered. It also disguises the fact the quarter has continued to see extraordinary movements in the prices of assets and has remained dominated by the same macroeconomic issues that led to the major market correction through the previous quarter.

October saw a broad rally in equity markets with the S&P 500 recording its best monthly gain since December 1991. Hong Kong's Hang Seng index rose 11% in the final week of October alone. These rallies presaged a positive outcome at the much anticipated EU summit late in October where it was initially perceived politicians were committed to making progress on resolution of the Eurozone debt issue. In what has become a recurring theme, the subsequent policy detail failed to live up to the political rhetoric prompting a swift reversal in markets with the FTSE 100 falling over 6% within two days as we entered November. November then saw a volatile downturn in equity markets eradicating most of October's gains. As we headed towards December, the FTSE 100 saw nine days of consecutive losses for the first time in over twenty seven years. In the first half of December it was gold's turn with a 10% fall in price in two weeks raising doubts as to its safe haven status.

Market action across the period has also been heavily influenced by continuing concern that the outlook for global economic growth is declining and fears of a "hard landing" in China. These negative factors have however been offset by data from the US that has generally continued to surprise to the upside. As December has progressed, we have seen greater policy action from central banks to address immediate liquidity concerns in the European financial sector, including the introduction of longer term re-financing arrangements for maturing debt. In current investment parlance, this seems to have "kicked the can" a little further down the road buying time for policymakers, and while the cost of holding perceived safe haven assets remains at or close to record levels, the end of the year has seen volatility reducing as market reaction to economic data has become more sanguine. It is clear however that significant economic challenges do remain ahead in 2012.

The annual inflation rate in the UK has fallen slightly from its peak but currently remains substantially above the Bank of England target. The Bank itself now expects inflation to fall sharply in early 2012 as the impact of rising VAT, energy and import prices declines. This should alleviate any pressure to raise interest rates which we expect to remain at their current low levels into the medium term. The ECB policy rate was cut by new president Mario Draghi and is also expected to ease further as recession becomes a dominant concern in the Eurozone.

UK equities advanced through the quarter with the FTSE 100 finishing up over 8%. The strongest performance was seen amongst defensive large-cap companies with global reach as investors focused on solid dividend paying stocks. Performance has not been so strong in smaller caps and those companies more exposed to the domestic economy where unemployment remains high, consumer confidence depressed and growth is forecast to be flat into next year as the government continues to implement austerity measures, and recession in Europe impacts on external trade.

European equity markets staged a small recovery off a low base with the MSCI Europe index rising some 6% over the quarter. However, negotiations to address the Eurozone debt crisis continue and are currently dominated by Germany's insistence that much greater fiscal responsibility be imposed on peripheral nations, and that debt reduction be achieved through austerity rather than through fiscal transfer between Eurozone nations and improving the competitiveness of debt-laden nations. This strategy, coupled with uncertainty over the survival of the Eurozone in its current form, continues to pose a risk to any hopes for a sustainable European equity market recovery.

US equities saw the strongest rises in the quarter with the S&P 500 gaining over 11%. This gain meant that, notwithstanding the extreme turbulence and negativity in markets in the last six months, the index ended the year at exactly the same level as it started. Economic data, corporate earnings and business surveys through the quarter have raised the possibility that America may be embarking on a sustainable recovery as we head into a presidential election year, although the sustainability of growing US public debt remains a significant concern.

Japan was the only major developed market to fall in the period with the Nikkei 225 declining by just under 3% to its lowest year end close since 1982. The index has suffered a significant annual fall over a year in which the earthquake and tsunami in March, the declining outlook for global growth, and a strong yen, have impacted negatively on its industrial capacity and export led economy.

Emerging markets as measured by the MSCI Emerging Markets index saw a gain of over 4% in the period, although the performance of these markets has varied. The best gains were seen in Latin American markets, including Brazil, whilst Asian markets have lagged. India under-performed as it continues to fight inflation, while easing inflation in China has allowed monetary policy to be loosened in order to support moderating economic growth as China seeks to allay fears of a "hard landing".

Bond markets again saw a volatile quarter as sentiment veered between deep fear and cautious optimism in response to ongoing developments in the Eurozone debt crisis. Perceived safe haven assets such as UK gilts and US treasuries ended the period with yields continuing to sit at or near historic lows, while those countries at the centre of the Eurozone crisis, such as Italy and Spain, saw yields rising rapidly in November to exceed 7%, raising the spectre of sovereign default. Co-ordinated central bank intervention to add liquidity to the financial sector in December, and introdution of a re-financing programme by the ECB, did however lead to reducing volatility and saw riskier fixed income assets start to rally towards the year end.

Our comments below relate to our general approach to portfolios over the period. Actual activity on trading accounts may differ from this depending on personal circumstances, please refer to your Valuation and Transaction Statements for details.




Portfolio Activity

With volatility continuing at high levels, large daily price swings and uncertainty over the outcome of the Eurozone debt crisis, the Investment Committee has generally maintained a policy of holding to the tactical positions taken in the previous quarter. Equity markets have traded sideways within a broad range through the period reflecting the uncertainty of investors over the short and medium term direction of markets. The tactical positions taken increase exposure to those equities expected to benefit most from any sustained market rally while an element of cash continues to be held to take advantage of any further market weakness.

Towards the end of the quarter the Investment Committee did sell positions in the Legal & General Growth fund in order to reinvest in the Cazenove UK Opportunities fund. The Investment Committee consider the Cazenove fund's business cycle based strategy, and ability to invest across the full market cap spectrum, provide greater opportunity for returns in current market conditions than the Legal & General fund. The Cazenove fund has a strong track record in rising and falling markets while the Legal & General fund's focus on potential M&A opportunities has led to under-performance and this is not expected to change.

Stock Market
Stock Market Index 1 Oct 2011 31 Dec 2011 Change %
Gilts FTSE British Gov All Stocks 166.46 173.57 4.27%
UK Large Cap FTSE-100 5,128.48 5,572.28 8.65%
UK Mid Cap FTSE-250 9,819.39 10,102.90 2.89%
US S&P 500 1,131.42 1,257.60 11.15%
Europe ex-UK MSCI Europe ex-UK 745.78 791.737 6.16%
Japan Nikkei 225 8,700.29 8,445.35 -2.82%
Emerging Markets MSCI Emerging Markets 39,248.12 41,012.76 4.5%
UK Commercial Property IPD UK All Property* 148.79 149.00 0.14%
Economic Measures 1 Oct 2011 31 Dec 2011 Change %
Inflation RPI* 236.10 238.50 1.02%
Cash UK Base Rate 0.5% 0.5% 0.00%
Association of Private Client Investment Managers Indices 1 Oct 2011 31 Dec 2011 Change %
FTSE APCIMS Balanced Portfolio 2735.10 2,894.64 5.83%
FTSE APCIMS Growth Portfolio 3,041.81 3,229.81 6.18%
FTSE APCIMS Income Portfolio 2188.35 2,311.14 5.61%

[Source: FE] *Values between 30th August 2011 and 30th November 2011 as end of quarter figure not yet published. ** Values for start and end of 3 month period ending 15th November 2011 as this is the most recent published data.

A

A - S&P 500 in US [11.15%]

B - FTSE 100 in GB [8.65%]

C - MSCI EUROPE ex UK [-20.09%]

D - MSCIEM (EMERGING MARKETS) [4.50%]

E - FTSE British Government All Stocks in GB [4.27%]

F - FTSE 250 Index in GB [2.89%]

G - IPD UK all property in GB [0.7%]

H - Nikkei 225 in JP [-2.82%]

30/06/2011 - 30/09/2011 ©Data provided by Financial Express 2011




House View

The Investment Committee expects little change in the outlook for markets as we move into 2012. Near-term market direction is likely to continue being dictated by short term swings in sentiment. This is a function of the sheer magnitude of ongoing issues still to be resolved in the global economy that will inevitably take some time to work through. These issues include: the European sovereign debt crisis and political moves seeking to forge closer fiscal union in the Eurozone; increasing global trade imbalances between strong surplus countries such as Germany and China and their trading partners; and the battle between inflationary and deflationary forces in the economy as central banks seek to address a loss of appetite for further credit creation which has been a significant driver for economic growth in developed economies in recent years.

On the positive side, the last few weeks of 2011 have seen a steady decline in indices measuring volatility levels as market behaviour has moved from knee-jerk reaction to political rhetoric and rumour of imminent economic catastrophe, to a more measured reaction to economic data, and policy development and implementation. Recent positive economic data from the US suggesting America may be on the road to a sustainable economic recovery is providing some welcome distraction from the global economy's obsessive focus with the Eurozone, and if maintained, would likely have a positive influence on equity markets generally. Equity markets remain cheap by historical standards and are demonstrating a tendency to rise on any vaguely positive news.

The Investment Committee is therefore maintaining a tactical tilt towards equities in its portfolio positioning in order to benefit from the potential for a rising equity market trend in the medium term while remaining cognizant of the possibility of shock events leading to further market declines. A small overweight cash position continues to be held pending a suitable opportunity to increase exposure to equity markets.

The Investment Committee continues to remain underweight within the fixed income asset class. A low exposure to high quality government debt has continued to detract from portfolio performance during the fourth quarter as the appetite for safe haven assets that effectively guarantee a negative real rate of return has remained strong. The Investment Committee continues to see little upside potential in these assets where any small increase in yield may now cause significant capital losses. Fixed interest exposure therefore remains weighted towards investment grade corporates, emerging market debt, and lower grade bonds.

Alternative exposure remains mildly overweight compared to benchmark. Funds with alternative investment strategies help to preserve capital through uncertain times whilst also aiming for returns above cash from hedging strategies. Exposure to commercial property remains underweight relative to benchmark with holdings maintained primarily for income yielding and diversification purposes.

In summary, we remain cautiously optimistic that the worst case scenarios currently being priced into markets will be found to be overly pessimistic as the year progresses leaving room for positive returns in equity and corporate credit markets.